Article: Befriend A Doc
Gain An Ally
Originally Published in
Materials Management in Healthcare Magazine, April 1999 issue.
Push or
pull physicians in the direction of change, and they’ll
probably resist. Embrace them instead and you may gain
their acceptance. The idea is to build physicians’
respect and confidence in you. This sets the stage for
effective value analysis. Use an approach we call the
“circle of confluence,” which incorporates four Cs:
contact, champions, communication and cooperation.
First, it’s crucial to establish regular contact with
physicians. Naturally, you’ll want to conduct focus
groups and surveys to understand their needs and ideas.
But it takes a little more effort to build lasting
relationships. Identify and be active in
committees
that are central to physicians’ deepest interests, such
as infection control, the operating room and quality.
To prove you are committed to their interests, sponsor
in-house seminars on new modalities, procedures and
therapies. Grab their attention with seminars on
products like silver-coated catheters, which can reduce nosocomial infections.
Project champions pave the way
Physicians respect
their peers, so cultivate relationships with ones who
will champion a cause and lead teams or committees
toward common goals. For example, the value analysis
process at Pennsylvania Hospital is very successful, in
part because physicians themselves lead the teams.
Regular communication is fundamental. It gives
physicians the opportunity to share and digest diverse
ideas. It can also generate new ideas by putting old
ones into context. Publish newsletters to keep
physicians fully informed about your philosophies and
actions and aware of your sensitivity to their needs.
Ask for the opportunity to present new programs and
initiatives at medical staff meetings and luncheons.
Most of all, truly listen when physicians tell you about
their concerns and problems. Then act to resolve them.
By serving and working with physicians without expecting
anything in return, you’ll build lasting alliances. For
instance, lead the way to facilitate capital equipment
requests and resolve product and quality problems.
Combined with contact, champion development and
communication, this will bring confluence full circle
and enable cooperation on common goals and challenges.
The circle of confluence is a continuous process, not a
onetime event. Keep the loop closed by continuing to
build on the four Cs.
Basis for value analysis With mutual respect and
confidence established through the circle of confluence,
you can take full advantage of the ultimate cost-cutting
tool—value analysis. Provided you remember one,
often-forgotten, principle: Value analysis is based on
studying the function or purpose of a product or
service. Once functions are fully understood, exact
functional specifications can be written for the item.
This is the foundation for finding lower-cost,
equivalent products. (See “Putting the ‘value’ in value
analysis,” September 1998.)
Who
“owns” a product? Time to set the record straight:
Groups of physicians don’t have widespread control over
purchases—individual physicians have control over
specific purchases. In any set of physicians, only
about 10 percent can be considered “owners” of a
particular product or service, and another 10 percent
may be “stakeholders.” A Full 80 percent have no
ownership or vested interest. Part of our job is to
identify the owners and stakeholders and meet their
requirements. Strong alliances can help you identify
every physician who “owns” a particular product or has a
vested interest in it—and keep you from omitting
anyone. Fail to include anyone who holds a stake in the
decision, and the project itself may fail. Such
alliances also set the stage for the next, difficult
step: learning the precise needs, functions and
features required of a product, translating them into
language everyone understands, and writing new
specifications for an alternative product that meets
those requirements. The result: Whole new vistas begin
to open up in the areas of savings and quality
improvement opportunities. A collaborative atmosphere
enables everyone to see these opportunities, digest
them, and act cooperatively. It all starts with the
four Cs.